Skip to content

EXCLUSIVE: Metro-North derailment engineer to undergo evaluation for sleep disorder: source

  • The train was going 82 mph before it derailed. The...

    Michael Schwartz for New York Daily News

    The train was going 82 mph before it derailed. The crash killed four and injured 75.

  • Rescue workers help passengers who had been on the Metro-North...

    Felix Lam/for New York Daily News

    Rescue workers help passengers who had been on the Metro-North train when it derailed near the Spuyten Duyvil station in the Bronx.

  • Reverend Eric Cosentino leads Ferrari's family and friends to the...

    Richard Harbus for New York Daily News

    Reverend Eric Cosentino leads Ferrari's family and friends to the cemetery, where they placed a rose on the casket.

  • Metro-North engineer William Rockefeller is loaded into an ambulance after...

    Eric Thayer/Reuters

    Metro-North engineer William Rockefeller is loaded into an ambulance after a train derailment in the Bronx on Sunday.

  • A mourner stands beside the casket of crash victim James...

    John Minchillo/AP

    A mourner stands beside the casket of crash victim James Ferrari before it is lowered into his grave plot in Weschester County.

  • A wake was held for Donna Smith, who died in...

    AP

    A wake was held for Donna Smith, who died in Sunday's Metro-North train derailment.

of

Expand
AuthorAuthorAuthor
PUBLISHED: | UPDATED:

Sleep apnea may have caused the locomotive engineer in the deadly Metro-North crash to zone out just before the train tumbled off the tracks.

William Rockefeller is expected to undergo an evaluation for the sleep disorder, a process that requires overnight monitoring, a source told the Daily News on Thursday.

Sleep apnea causes sufferers to stop breathing repeatedly while they are snoozing — leaving them exhausted when they finally wake up.

A mourner stands beside the casket of crash victim James Ferrari before it is lowered into his grave plot in Weschester County.
A mourner stands beside the casket of crash victim James Ferrari before it is lowered into his grave plot in Weschester County.

They often don’t realize they have it, the American Sleep Apnea Association said.

It is a “debilitating and life-shortening ailment that’s estimated to affect 22 million Americans,” according to the group. “Untreated, it can lead to depression, heart disease, diabetes and fatal car crashes.”

The Bronx-born Ferrari leaves behind a wife and 20-year-old daughter.
The Bronx-born Ferrari leaves behind a wife and 20-year-old daughter.

Portly people like Rockefeller are more prone to suffer from sleep apnea, experts said.

It has become such a problem that the Federal Aviation Administration recently announced a plan to screen overweight and obese pilots for the condition — and ground those who have it until they are treated by a sleep expert.

Reverend Eric Cosentino leads Ferrari's family and friends to the cemetery, where they placed a rose on the casket.
Reverend Eric Cosentino leads Ferrari’s family and friends to the cemetery, where they placed a rose on the casket.

Rockefeller, 46 of Germantown, N.Y., is on unpaid leave and has stayed out of sight since the Sunday morning crash in the Bronx, which left four passengers dead and 75 more injured.

His lawyer, Jeffrey Chartier, did not return a call for comment.

Metro-North engineer William Rockefeller is loaded into an ambulance after a train derailment in the Bronx on Sunday.
Metro-North engineer William Rockefeller is loaded into an ambulance after a train derailment in the Bronx on Sunday.

But immediately after the wreck, Rockefeller told cops, “I was in a daze,” The News reported on Tuesday.

That was followed by claims from a honcho in Rockefeller’s union who said he “basically nodded” just before the train — barreling down the tracks at 82 mph — derailed on a treacherous curve north of the Spuyten Duyvil station.

<img loading="" class="lazyload size-article_feature" data-sizes="auto" alt="

The train was going 82 mph before it derailed. The crash killed four and injured 75.

” title=”

The train was going 82 mph before it derailed. The crash killed four and injured 75.

” data-src=”/wp-content/uploads/migration/2013/12/06/7FG44IZNQFI6LTHLZFBQH55JPU.jpg”>

The train was going 82 mph before it derailed. The crash killed four and injured 75.

Anthony Bottalico, director of the Association of Commuter Rail Employees, also insisted that Rockefeller was not sleep-deprived.

The National Transportation Safety Board, which is investigating the catastrophe, agreed that Rockefeller had plenty time to recharge his batteries. But the feds declined to comment on Bottalico’s claim that Rockefeller zoned out at the controls.

Rescue workers help passengers who had been on the Metro-North train when it derailed near the Spuyten Duyvil station in the Bronx.
Rescue workers help passengers who had been on the Metro-North train when it derailed near the Spuyten Duyvil station in the Bronx.

Meanwhile, the MTA has admitted that Rockefeller’s train was equipped with an “alerter” system designed to rouse a dozing driver. But it was in the locomotive, which was pushing the train down the tracks from the back.

Rockefeller was operating the train from the first car when it headed into a treacherous curve where trains are supposed to slow down from 70 mph to just 30 mph.

A wake was held for Donna Smith, who died in Sunday's Metro-North train derailment.
A wake was held for Donna Smith, who died in Sunday’s Metro-North train derailment.

The developments Thursday came as wrenching wakes got underway for victims James Lovell and Donna Smith and a third victim, James Ferrari, was buried after a funeral mass.

Smith, 54, of Newburgh, N.Y., was heading into the city to hear her sister, Linda, sing Handel’s “Messiah” at the Lincoln Center when she was killed.

A photo taken inside the derailed train.
A photo taken inside the derailed train.

At Smith’s wake, they played “Amazing Grace” while Linda Smith stood beside her sister’s flower-laden coffin.

“Thanks for your support,” she told well-wishers. “That’s what I can feel. That’s what gets me through.”

Another photo from inside the train shows some of the damage that was done.
Another photo from inside the train shows some of the damage that was done.

Outside the funeral home, Linda Smith’s friend Irene Scott-Bethea said it was a comfort to see so many people come to pay their respects.

“She’s holding up great,” Scott-Bethea said of her friend. “See everyone here is giving her strength.”

Along with the passengers, the derailment caused significant damage to the interior and exterior of the train.
Along with the passengers, the derailment caused significant damage to the interior and exterior of the train.

Funeral plans for the fourth victim, Kisook Ahn, were still being finalized.

Meanwhile, another crash survivor, Kelon McFarlane, was expected to announce his intention to sue the MTA, bringing the total who have taken legal action thus far to three.

With Dareh Gregorian

pdonohue@nydailynews.com